“‘Impossible’ for Pell to reveal genitals from under robes, court told” & related articles

Share Button

The Age

22 March 2018 — 5:53pm

It would have been impossible for then-archbishop George Pell to reveal his genitals after officiating at a Sunday Mass without somebody helping him to remove his clerical robes, a Catholic pastoral associate has told a Melbourne court.

Rodney Dearing, who was a choir member at St Patrick’s Cathedral in Melbourne during the late 1990s, told the Melbourne Magistrates Court on Thursday that Cardinal Pell would have required assistance to remove his robe after every Mass.

Cardinal Pell celebrating Mass at St Patricks' in 2001.

Cardinal Pell celebrating Mass at St Patricks’ in 2001.

Photo: Ken Irwin

Cardinal Pell, 76, faces multiple historical sexual offence charges involving multiple complainants. He is facing a hearing to determine whether he stands trial. Details of the charges are yet to be revealed. He has repeatedly denied the allegations.

Mr Dearing said the robes were heavy and detailed and “not something that was easy to manoeuvre”.

He said Cardinal Pell would have required help to dress and undress before and after each Mass.

During cross-examination, one of Cardinal Pell’s defence barristers, Ruth Shann, asked Mr Dearing: “It [the robe] was not able to be parted in the middle to reveal one’s genitals? Or indeed, parted to one side to reveal one’s genitals?”

Mr Dearing responded “No.”

The court also heard one of the sexual assault allegations Cardinal Pell faced involved two choristers who allegedly disappeared from a procession from the cathedral after Mass.

Mr Dearing also told the court that choir members at St Patrick’s began to be more closely monitored in the late 1990s after sexual assault allegations began to emerge about other Catholic clergy.

When asked about sexual assault allegations levelled at Cardinal Pell, Mr Dearing said he had never seen the then-archbishop do anything untoward.

Cardinal George Pell outside Melbourne Magistrates Court this week.

Cardinal George Pell outside Melbourne Magistrates Court this week.

Photo: AAP

Mr Dearing told police: “I can’t understand knowing the layout [of the cathedral] and how things worked, how it could have occurred.”

The court has not released details about the charges.

But the defence has cross-examined witnesses about their interactions with Cardinal Pell at a swimming pool, cinema, and a lake in rural Victoria, and other locations.

Cardinal Pell is accused of abusing a complainant while watching the film Close Encounters of the Third Kind at a country Victorian cinema, and abusing another complainant at a community pool.

The hearing also heard from five other witnesses, including four former choir members and Christian Brother Peter Finnigan who was choir marshall at St Patrick’s Cathedral during the late 1990s.

The hearing, before Magistrate Belinda Wallington, continues.

 ________________________________

Church robes focus in Cardinal George Pell’s court case

A WITNESS believes Cardinal George Pell would not have been able to remove the ceremonial robes he was wearing on the day he is accused of committing a sex offence.

news.com.au

AAP
March 22, 20188:05pm
Jacqueline Le

CARDINAL George Pell would have been restricted by the ceremonial robes he was wearing on the day he is accused of committing a sex offence, a court has been told.

A witness, who cannot be named for legal reasons, also said he did not believe the alleged incident occurred based on his knowledge of a church’s layout.

Pell, 76, has been charged with multiple historical sex offences, which he is fighting at a committal hearing before Melbourne Magistrates Court that will determine if he stands trial.

A parish staff member on Thursday said the ceremonial robes worn by Pell at the time of an alleged offence were heavy and consisted of multiple layers.

“If we take the entirety of what he is wearing, which you have described in your statement, it was a significant number of items, correct? Heavy?” defence barrister Ruth Shann said during cross-examination.

“Yes,” the man replied.

“Unable to be manoeuvred easily?” Ms Shann asked.

“I would say so,” he replied.

“Requiring people to help robe and disrobe?” she continued.

“Absolutely,” the witness said.

When asked by Ms Shann whether the robes could be parted on the side or the middle, the man said they could not.

The man, who was also a choir member, told the hearing he had extensive experience with church robes after helping various clergy prepare for mass and other ceremonies.

The parish staff member previously told police he and other staff were always present at the time the alleged sex offences were to have taken place.

“I can’t understand, knowing the layout and how things work, how they occurred,” he told police in June 2017, before Pell was charged.

“From your perspective, it’s just not possible?” Ms Shann asked on Thursday.

“I don’t believe so,” the witness said.

Pell has been charged with multiple historical sex offences involving multiple complainants.

The court has not released details about the charges.

But the defence has cross-examined witnesses about their interactions with Pell at a swimming pool, cinema, and a lake in rural Victoria, and other locations.

The pre-trial hearing before magistrate Belinda Wallington will resume on Friday.

______________________________________

Cardinal George Pell’s alleged offending at cathedral couldn’t have happened, court told

ABC News Australia

22 March 2018

Photo:George Pell, in 2002, when he was archbishop of Sydney. (Mark Baker, file photo: Reuters)

A former choir member has told a court he does not believe Cardinal George Pell could have sexually offended against choristers at Melbourne’s St Patrick’s Cathedral “knowing the layout and how things worked”.

Rodney Dearing has given evidence in the Melbourne Magistrates Court as Cardinal Pell, 76, fights historical sexual offence charges involving multiple complainants.

No other details of the charges can be reported for legal reasons.

The court was told that one of the allegations levelled at Cardinal Pell involved two of the choristers during the choir’s procession outside the cathedral at the end of mass in the late 1990s.

Mr Dearing agreed with Cardinal Pell’s defence barrister Ruth Shann that if two choristers had “nicked-off” they would have been noticed by other choir members.

The court heard that Mr Dearing told investigating police he had discussed the allegations made against Cardinal Pell during his time as archbishop after they had been published in a book.

“I can’t understand, knowing the layout and how things worked, how it could have occurred,” he told police.

Ms Shann again asked Mr Dearing if he stood by that statement “that from your perspective it’s just not possible,” she asked.

“I don’t believe so,” Mr Dearing replied.

He also agreed that the archbishop’s robes couldn’t be moved to the side or parted in the middle to allow him to reveal his genitals.

Mr Dearing told the court the archbishop’s robes were heavy, difficult to manoeuvre and required another person to help put them on and take them off.

The complainants gave their evidence during the first two weeks of the committal hearing via video link and in a closed court.

Therefore their evidence is unable to be reported.

The committal hearing is expected to run until next Thursday.

Magistrate Belinda Wallington will then rule on whether there’s enough evidence to commit Cardinal Pell to stand trial.

 _______________________________________

‘Impossible’ for Pell to reveal genitals from under robes, court told

Brisbane Times

22 March 2018 — 4:53pm

By Melissa Cunningham

It would have been impossible for then-archbishop George Pell to reveal his genitals after officiating at a Sunday Mass without somebody helping him to remove his clerical robes, a Catholic pastoral associate has told a Melbourne court.

Rodney Dearing, who was a choir member at St Patrick’s Cathedral in Melbourne during the late 1990s, told the Melbourne Magistrates Court on Thursday that Cardinal Pell would have required assistance to remove his robe after every Mass.

Cardinal Pell celebrating Mass at St Patricks' in 2001.

Cardinal Pell celebrating Mass at St Patricks’ in 2001.

Photo: Ken Irwin

Cardinal Pell, 76, faces multiple historical sexual offence charges involving multiple complainants. He is facing a hearing to determine whether he stands trial. Details of the charges are yet to be revealed. He has repeatedly denied the allegations.

Mr Dearing said the robes were heavy and detailed and “not something that was easy to manoeuvre”.

He said Cardinal Pell would have required help to dress and undress before and after each Mass.

______________________________________________

Cardinal George Pell: court told archbishop robes could not be easily removed

Pastoral associate agrees that robes not able to be parted to ‘reveal one’s genitals’

The Guardian

Thu 22 Mar 2018

Cardinal George Pell

Cardinal George Pell arrives at Melbourne magistrates court. He is the highest ranking Vatican official to be charged in the Catholic church’s sexual abuse scandal. Photograph: James Ross/AAP

A pastoral associate who worked at St Patrick’s Cathedral in Melbourne when Cardinal George Pell was archbishop has told a court that the archbishop’s robes were heavy and could not be easily lifted or moved while being worn to expose oneself.

Rodney Dearing was cross-examined by Pell’s defence team on Thursday as part of the committal hearing into historical sexual offence charges against Pell. Dearing told the court that he was responsible for hanging up Pell’s robes and he was therefore familiar with the weight and manoeuvrability of them.

Pell’s barrister Ruth Shann put it to Dearing that the robes were “not able to be parted in the middle to reveal ones genitals or indeed parted to the side to reveal ones genitals”.

“No,” Dearing responded.

The court heard that two of the choir boys had said they had “snuck back inside” the cathedral building as the procession exited the building. But Shann told Dearing that there was a general awareness at the time Pell was archbishop of Melbourne, from 1996, “of allegations coming out generally about clergy and kids”, which would have “motivated you personally and fellow adult chorists to keep a particularly close eye on the kids”. Dearing agreed.

The defence has been cross-examining former choir boys and staff at the cathedral at the time Pell was archbishop, and suggesting to them that two missing boys would have been noticed due to the strict expectation that choirboys were to follow the rules, the close eye staff kept on the choir and the layout of the building and grounds.

On Thursday morning Peter Finnigan, who used to manage the choir, told the defence team that while he did not recall two boys going missing at any stage, “it would certainly be possible”.

“But they would certainly be very naughty boys if they did,” he said.

Pell is the highest-ranking Vatican official to be charged in the Catholic church’s long-running sexual abuse scandal. He has taken leave from the Vatican in Rome to attend court. He has strenuously denied all allegations.

When the hearing adjourns magistrate Belinda Wallington will need to decide if there is enough evidence to order Pell to stand trial accused of historical sexual offences. Further description of the charges cannot be given for legal reasons.

The committal hearing continues.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *