Canon François Sarrazin said the policy doesn’t only apply to priests but to all employees of parishes and churches, volunteers and “anyone else in the orbit of the diocese.”
The Toronto Star
Thu., June 23, 2016
MONTREAL—Priests and anyone else in “the orbit of the church” will be forbidden from being alone with children and other vulnerable people as part of a pilot project, the Roman Catholic archdiocese of Montreal said Thursday.
The goal is to create a “safety net” for everyone associated with the Catholic Church in Montreal, canon François Sarrazin said in an interview.
“Imagine if you are alone in a room and a child accuses you of hitting them, how will you react?” Sarrazin asked. “Whether it’s true or not, you need a witness. Not being in the room alone with someone who is vulnerable is simply being prudent.”
He said the policy will be introduced in a handful of churches across the city, starting in September.
For Carlo Tarini, a spokesman for an association of victims of priests, the new rules are “too little too late.”
He said the policy is just a way for the church to protect itself against lawsuits stemming from child-abuse scandals that have rocked the city’s diocese and the Roman Catholic Church across the globe.
The church “knows that victims have gotten help from lawyers and have been successful in court and they will push forward for compensation when such cases are made public,” Tarini said.
Recently, the Clerics of St-Viateur, a Catholic religious order that ran a school for deaf children in Montreal, was sued after 150 people came forward to say they were victims of child abuse at the boarding school between 1940 and the early ‘80s.
Between November and February, the order, along with a Quebec government-run health institute that took over the school, reached an out-of-court settlement with the plaintiffs for $30 million — reportedly the largest sum awarded to victims of a church sex-abuse scandal in Quebec.
Sarrazin said the policy doesn’t only apply to priests but to all employees of parishes and churches, volunteers and “anyone else in the orbit of the diocese.”
Archbishop of Montreal Christian Lépine said in a statement he will create a new bureau in the diocese called the “Service of Responsible Pastoral Ministry,” which will be tasked with rolling out the new policy.
Sarrazin said details will be made available at a later date.
Montreal priests to be prohibited from being alone with children
Pilot project known as ‘Responsible Pastoral Ministry’ scheduled to begin later this year
Posted: Jun 23, 2016 8:56 AM ET Last Updated: Jun 23, 2016 5:12 PM ET
By Kamila Hinkson, Sabrina Marandola
The Catholic Church of Montreal plans to bar priests, volunteers and all those involved in faith education from being alone with children.
François Sarrazin, chancellor of the Montreal Archdiocese, said a pilot project — to begin in 10 churches later this year — is a preventative measure and that churches in other provinces including Ontario have already implemented similar policies.
“It’s important that the church shows it’s making an effort and that our society can have confidence in the church and can say ‘they did their homework, now they’re credible,'” he said.
The pilot will involve French-speaking, English-speaking and parishes from various cultural communities that volunteer to participate and diocesan offices and services.
Sarrazin said it’s important to protect not just children, but all vulnerable people who seek out pastoral care, including the elderly.
‘Protecting the church’
The measure is part of a policy the archdiocese is calling “Responsible Pastoral Ministry.”
Sarrazin said while the church has been rocked in recent years by allegations of sexual abuse of children, those allegations aren’t always founded.
“To give [their story] importance, a child can give an account of an incident that isn’t always true,” he said.
For that reason, the policy is already in place, but in an unofficial capacity, Sarrazin said.
When asked to clarify the reasons behind the policy, Sarrazin named three.
“Protecting victims, protecting families, protecting the church,” he said.
Sarrazin told Radio-Canada a child would be accompanied by their parents for rites such as confession. The parents would be sitting further away, but would still be able to see their child.
‘Damage control,’ victims’ group says
Quebec’s Association of Victims of Priests calls the move too little, too late.
“This is damage control. The church has suffered a lot of flak because of its inaction about pedophile priests. But this is just a baby step. It needs to do an awful lot more,” said Carlo Tarini, a spokesman for the group.
John Zucchi, a professor in the department of history and classical studies at Montreal’s McGill University, said the pilot project is a first step.
“Many of these victims have a very painful past and suffered unjustly … I understand their frustration … The local diocese is going to take this one step at a time. If these guidelines are not enough, I’m sure there will be more action.”
He added that the Vatican will be watching closely.
“Historically, there have been people, religious people, who have called for safeguards — it’s come from the grassroots. But this time here in particular it’s coming from Rome — the Vatican, Pope Benedict and now Pope Francis who pushed for all types of safeguards. The dioceses around the world have been following on these indications from Rome.”
with files from Alison Northcott and Justin Hayward
New guidelines forbid Montreal Catholic priests, lay workers to be alone with children
The National Post
June 23, 2016 7:40 PM ET
More from Graeme Hamilton | @grayhamilton
Pierre Obendrauf/Postmedia News/FileChristian Lépine, archbishop of Montreal: “People who work in churches, if they hope to hide to commit acts of pedophilia, these people have no place in the service of the church.”
MONTREAL – Invoking past sexual abuse scandals and the need to create a “healthy and safe environment” in its churches, the Roman Catholic archdiocese of Montreal has announced new guidelines to ensure priests and lay workers are never alone with children.
“Recent events have brought to light the horrific reality of abuse of minors and vulnerable persons by members of the Church,” Christian Lépine, archbishop of Montreal, wrote in a message to the faithful dated Wednesday.
“These intolerable situations have shocked and shaken the Universal Church as well as the entire population to whom we wish to proclaim the Good News of Christ.”
A pilot project to begin this fall in 10 parishes and eventually extend to all 194 in Montreal will prohibit priests, staff and volunteers from being alone with minors. Following the lead of other organizations like amateur sport associations and the Scouts, the archdiocese will institute police screening of new hires and volunteers working with children or the vulnerable.
François Sarrazin, chancellor of the archdiocese, said the measures are intended to send a message.
“People who work in churches, if they hope to hide to commit acts of pedophilia, these people have no place in the service of the church,” he said.
Simple human prudence dictates that you don’t remain alone with a child.
The archdiocese is drawing on similar projects in Ontario and New Brunswick, he said.
In Bathurst, N.B., for example, the 2015 diocesan policy for responsible pastoral ministries states: “Members of the clergy, pastoral agents, employees or volunteers must avoid being alone in a closed area with a minor, unless there is another screened adult or the minor’s parents/guardians close by.”
It is a far cry from the days when Sarrazin, 67, was a boy entering the confessional booth with his heart beating and the priest on other side of the screen. These days, he said, when priests meet children, it may be out of earshot but it is always in full view of another adult.
“Simple human prudence dictates that you don’t remain alone with a child,” Sarrazin said.
In an interview with the Journal de Montréal, the archbishop called sexual abuse that occurred within the church “an unspeakable tragedy,” but said the institution has evolved.
“At one time, it was thought that (pedophilia) did not exist,” he said. “At another, it was thought to be curable, and priests were given a therapy session before being sent back to their ministry. Today, we know it exists, and we have to act.”
For Sébastien Richard, spokesman for a Quebec association of victims abused by priests, the new measures announced by the archdiocese are worthy, but they arrive too late.
With church attendance in steep decline, priests are an endangered species, he said. The potential for abuse is reduced simply by their dwindling numbers and by the fact they are no longer teaching in schools.
If the archbishop truly believes in addressing the “unspeakable tragedy” of past abuse, the church should stop invoking prescription – that too much time has passed since alleged events occurred — when facing civil suits from abuse victims, Richard said.
“Right now, there are hundreds, even thousands of victims of childhood sexual abuse, committed by priests and clergy, who are denied justice because the Catholic Church insists on invoking prescription so as to not have to compensate the victims,” he said.
Montreal priests no longer allowed being alone with children
The Archbishop of Montreal is going to implement a pilot project this fall in hopes of cleaning up the reputation of the Catholic Church.
In an interview with the Journal de Montreal, Archbishop Christian Lépine said that Montreal priests will be barred from being alone with a child in order to prevent any opportunity for paedophilic acts.
Bishop Lépine said there will be a pilot project this fall in 10 parishes that could eventually be expanded island wide.
The Archbishop is also looking to prevent any possible situations of breach of trust by prohibiting Church employees from receiving personal gifts.
I’m puzzled by all the fanfare – hunted for and was unable to find a copy of the policy itself anywhere, then realized that “a guide” is to be “published and developed.”
Why not start the clean-up by defrocking all clergy in and/or from the archdiocese who are known molesters? Would that not be an obvious first step to, as the Archbishop said in a statement: “ensure a healthy and safe environment that is free of doubt for all who work within our churches…”
Yes, he completed that sentence with ” whether priests or lay people,” but for goodness sake let’s not cast the net far and wide, let’s start with the real problem at hand in the Church, that being molesters who are priests, – and, yes, also those men who are members of a religious order.
And would it not be a good idea to publish the names of all members of the clergy or religious orders in or from the Archdiocese who are known predators? would that not go a long long way to ensuring the well-being of the countless silent victims who still think that they are the only and that no one will believe them?
How sad that it has come to this. They just will not start with the first logical steps.
Now, all decent priests are under the microscope because bishops and diocesan authorities in diocese after diocese have consistently failed to identify and get rid of predatory clergy.
Until “the Church” tackles the problem head on by defrocking every single known predatory priest there is no choice but to point the finger of suspicion at all, and in consequence implement standards which relay a clear message that no priest can or is to be trusted.
Yes, alas, under the present circumstances wrought by our bishops prudence does indeed dictate that no child should be left alone in the company of a priest.
Exactly: without defrocking every convicted cleric-religious; it is impossible to reasonably know who’s who.
According to this silly public relations stunt; two religious perverts could rape a victim; coordinate their stories, and not violate the ban on being alone with a child. And this socially irresponsible entity which has been litigating the ying yang outta victims of clerical abuse is probably going to argue that two perverts operating together did not technically violate the policy.
The Church is still improvising it’s totally careless response to clerical abuse.
The idea that the ‘church’ the ‘vatican’ started this is just plain not true. The courageous victims who have come forward and put pressure on the church is the reason these things are happening. Their spin doctors don’t want to admit that so they want to put the ‘church’ in good light. In the article two statements stand out to me that indicate nothing has changed in how they view victims “To give [their story] importance, a child can give an account of an incident that isn’t always true,” he said. and “Imagine if you are alone in a room and a child accuses you of hitting them, how will you react?. What is he really saying with these comments, nothing good.
This is not about making a safety net, this is pure and simple about protecting the church, so nothing has changed. I have asked this question of those in diocese power before, how do you determine a vulnerable person? Mental capability? Psychological impairment? I have never been given a straight answer. It would be interesting to see what answer they give.
You can use words but until action happens they mean nothing. That vail of secrecy will still exist. People knew children were being abused, but said nothing, other priests knew of abuse, but said nothing, bishops knew abuse was going on and just moved them around. Once again what has changed? Nothing as long as comments like the ones I quoted they will still not believe anything. Nothing changes if there is no change.
I read it in the paper this am and I was perplexed to find it buried quietly on one of the inner pages nice and discreet so we won’t make a big deal of it….I must say though I’m happy for today when our sons and daughters are taught to speak up and don’t be afraid to tell…it’s the only way to stop these predators.
I am heartened by the statement from the Archbishop in one sense, but deeply saddened in another.
“If they hope to commit acts of paedophilia, these people have no place in the service of the church”. Thank God!! I hope he means it. Time will tell.
Having said this, I find myself wondering what Jesus Christ would have to say about priests who are not allowed to be alone with children. The Archdiocese is perhaps more worried (and untrusting) of their priests, and the resulting lawsuits than with the spiritual nurturing of our children. What have we become?????
I think the church can go a LONG way here in being more diligent in the recruitment of candidates to the priesthood, and in the “weeding-out” of the sick, deviant ones. I hope they do!
Carlo Tarini has said that the church is in “damage control” mode. Why did the church wait for so long, and allow such horrible damage to be done, before they actually did something concrete about it?
I just hope that this is not “blaming the children” as opposed to blaming “the good father”. Mike.
“Carlo Tarini has said that the church is in “damage control” mode. Why did the church wait for so long, and allow such horrible damage to be done, before they actually did something concrete about it?”
I hate to burst your bubble, Mike, but “the church” looks at their “problems” with pedophiles as just another bump in the road! Look at their track record, their accumulated wealth we can’t even start to comprehend and the passage of time will erase all traces of their “evil” ways ..except their position of power and control over the poor and credulous. THAT’s the wish they nurture and understand!. Every new story or revelation( how did that word sneak in here?…) will soon be forgotten with a dead abuser, a dead victim..many who worship every day or simply “parade”, will never hear of their failings or will simply dismiss it as an “attack” on the beloved church!
Do we trust “the church” to do the right thing anytime soon? Not on all our lives! They are living in that same ignorance with the rest of the world…they want to profit and control, and rule. Absolute ignorance, absolute arrogance calls for an absolute condemnation!
They are not doing anything right, they are FAILING!
You are right about the children, and the “Greatest teaching” about the care of children: they FAIL all the way on this with their lawyers, their delays, their lies, their money…
I just hope, in my lifetime, to see these monsters on their knees begging for their miserable souls and be treated as they treated the Lord’s children, with total indifference and scorn….
Thanks jg!!! You haven’t burst my bubble at all. I agree completely. Along with seeing the monsters and their enablers down on their knees, I am still somewhat hopeful that good can come of all this.
No, probably not in our lifetime, but constant pressure and challenge will eventually have it’s rewards.
Take care. Mike.