“Abuse survivor’s memories triggered after report on Catholic priest

Share Button

CTV News

Published Wednesday, February 20, 2019 10:00PM EST
Last Updated Thursday, February 21, 2019 9:58AM EST

CTVNews.ca Staff, with a report from CTV National News’ London correspondent Daniele Hamamdjian

Warning: This story contains graphic details of sexual abuse.

As Catholic Church officials meet with sex abuse survivors this week, some following the news may not even know they were also victims.

Jeffrey Fischer of London, Ont., was abused as a child going to church in nearby Guelph, but had largely repressed the incidents from his memory and was left with occasional visions.

“One of them was being a little kid and standing with my trousers down and everything above mid-level was foggy,” Fischer told CTV News.

His memories resurfaced back in August, when CTV News profiled a priest from Ireland who abused children before being transferred to Canada.

Father Arthur Carragher was transferred to the Saint Joseph’s Church in Guelph back in 1971, the same year a mother complained that he abused two boys in Ireland. Church documents do not indicate why Carragher moved to Canada. He retired in 1995 and died in 2011.

In the August story, Troy Bridgeman, a former altar boy at the Saint Joseph’s Church, indicates he was not abused as a child, but says Carragher used to tell him stories about a little boy who disobeyed his father and got trapped inside an airtight vault.

Fischer says he’s that little boy.

“I was shaking and our family knows we’re not very demonstrative of a family,” he said. “My brother just held me because I was shaking so much.”

Fischer says Carragher used to lock him in a bathroom while he made sure everyone else in the church had left, then he would return to fondle him while telling him it would help him become a man.

Fischer says once he saw an image of Carragher on the screen, the visions of what had happened to him came back like a “percussion from a bomb.”

“The immediate reaction was a sense of relief,” he said. “It was it. That was it. That’s what happened.”

He hopes opening up about his experience helps others with their repressed memories.

Report triggers repressed memory: ‘I was abused’

Daniele Hamamdjian, CTV News in Rome

It’s no exaggeration to say that it’s a privilege to do any kind of reporting that has the potential to affect people, and occasionally trigger change.

But rarely can it literally change the course of someone’s life.

This is what happened after we reported on a pedophile priest from Ireland who was transferred to Canada in 1971 after a complaint was made that he had abused two brothers.

Jeffrey Fischer wasn’t golfing like he normally would be on a sunny Saturday afternoon in August. He happened to be home alone while his wife and four daughters were out of town. A CTV report came on, two days after it originally aired, and in Fischer’s own words, it reverberated throughout his body.

He saw a photo of Fr. Arthur Carragher, now deceased, and instantly recognized him.

He called his brother, an OPP officer, and for the first time in his life said the words, “I was abused.”

How, for all those years, did he not remember that he was assaulted, that he was forced to stay quiet in a tiny bathroom at St. Joseph parish in Guelph while Fr. Carragher pulled down his pants and told him this is how he would become a man? Quite simply, he had blocked it out.

Since the story aired, we were made aware of two other men who say they were abused by Carragher at St. Joseph’s. The parish in Guelph, still fiercely Catholic, has raised his name once during Sunday mass and encouraged people to come forward, but no one has.

As one abuse survivor said this week in Rome, every time a victim speaks out, it gives another victim permission to do the same.

Fischer’s decision to let us tell his story was incredibly courageous and he did so with only one intention, to help at least one other person do the same.

  • Father Arthur Carragher Father Arthur Carragher admitted to sexually abusing children before his death in 2011.


Irish man shares story of sexual abuse by priest who later moved to Canada

GRAPHIC WARNING: A clerical abuse survivor in Ireland says Canada gave sanctuary to a pedophile priest. Daniele Hamamdjian reports.

Published Thursday, August 23, 2018 10:00PM EDT
Last Updated Friday, August 24, 2018 8:01AM EDT

Daniele Hamamdjian, CTV News

Warning: This story contains graphic details of sexual abuse.

DUBLIN, Ireland — An Irish man is speaking out about the childhood sexual abuse he suffered at the hands of a Catholic priest – a priest who later spent three decades in Canada.

Mark Vincent Healy says he is still tormented by the way Father Arthur Carragher fondled him in a locker room when he was only nine years old.

“He took my trousers down and he was fondling and masturbating me, and I said, ‘What are you doing to me?’ But I couldn’t get away. There was this authority figure that is now playing with you in away — ‘playing’ is a terrible word — was criminally assaulting you.”

Healy says he shut the memories out for decades. Then he had a nervous breakdown.

He went on to campaign for other victims of assault and was the first male survivor in Ireland to meet Pope Francis, who is under pressure to act on the growing global abuse scandal as he visits Dublin this weekend.

But now Healy is turning his attention to Canada, specifically, St. Joseph’s Parish in Guelph, Ont., where Carragher was transferred in 1971.

According to The Congregation of the Holy Ghost, nothing in Carragher’s file explained his transfer to Canada in 1971. It was also the same year a Dublin mother told school officials he had assaulted her two young boys.

The Congregation of the Holy Ghost, also known as the Spiritans, claims priests were sent to various parts of the world at that time. Victims say that is a convenient explanation, just not the actual one.

Carragher retired in 1995, one year before the formal accusations began to emerge.

In 2001, after Carragher confessed to molesting two Dublin boys in the 1960s, the congregation sent him for a six-day psychological assessment at Southdown, a facility where other priests accused of preying on children had been treated.

His victims say he told them, “this is what it feels like to be a man.”

There came a point when he was wanted in Dublin, but with no extradition treaty between Ireland and Canada, Carragher, even as a self-confessed child molested, lived out his last days in Toronto. He died in 2011.

Healy says he thinks more victims are out there and he doesn’t believe a word that Canadian church officials have told him.

He also feels he let his nine-year-old self down, but he is trying to seek his forgiveness.

“I didn’t help him,” he says. “It took a time for me to get over the guilt of all of this.”

Carragher had a particular “reprehensible interest in prepubescent boys,” Healy added, “perversely interested in forcing a child to a sexual awakening they hadn’t a clue about to which they had not even physically developed and to which they would never recover from psychologically.”

Healy doesn’t hold Canada responsible for “granting Carragher refuge.” He says Canada was also a potential victim of this man.

3 Responses to “Abuse survivor’s memories triggered after report on Catholic priest

  1. Sylvia says:

    “As one abuse survivor said this week in Rome, every time a victim speaks out, it gives another victim permission to do the same.”

    So very true. You each draw courage from the courage of others.

    Please keep all of Father Carragher’s victims in your prayers.

  2. Sylvia says:

    There’s some good coverage here. I can’t get the clip so will leave the YouTube link


  3. Troy Bridgeman says:

    Thanks for posting Sylvia and thanks for all your efforts to shine a light on this issue.

Leave a Reply