Vatican Eyes Legion Priests on Abuse

Share Button

time.com

11 May 2012

By AP / NICOLE WINFIELD

(VATICAN CITY) — The Vatican is investigating seven priests from the troubled Legion of Christ religious order for alleged sexual abuse of minors and another two for other alleged crimes, The Associated Press has learned.

The investigations mark the first known Vatican action against Legion priests for alleged sexual assault following the scandal of the Legion’s founder, who was long held up as a model by the Vatican despite credible accusations — later proven — that he raped and molested his seminarians.

The Legion, which is now under Vatican receivership, has insisted that the crimes of its late founder, the Rev. Marciel Maciel, were his alone.

But the Vatican investigation of other Legion priests indicates that the same culture of secrecy that Maciel created within the order to cover his crimes enabled other priests to abuse children — just as abusive clergy of other religious orders and dioceses have done around the world.

In a statement Friday to the AP, the Legion confirmed it had referred seven cases of alleged abuse to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican office that investigates sex crimes. All but one involves alleged abuse dating from decades ago; one case involves recent events, the Legion said.

While the investigation is under way, the accused priests are being kept away from children, the Legion said.

“Over the past few years, in several countries, the major superiors of the Legion of Christ have received some allegations of gravely immoral acts and more serious offenses … committed by some Legionaries,” the statement said.

It said it was committed to examining the accusations and reaching out to victims while safeguarding the rights of all involved.

The Legion issued the statement to the AP after the news organization approached it with the allegations; the Legion simultaneously sent the statement out to all priests in the order.

In addition to referring the cases to the Vatican as required by church law, the Legion said it had referred cases to police where civil reporting laws require it. It’s not clear, however, if any law enforcement action was taken given the statute of limitations may have expired for such old cases.

The Legion said two other priests are also under investigation by the Congregation for alleged sacramental violations, believed to involve using spiritual direction to have inappropriate relations with women.

Preliminary investigations of an unspecified number of other priests accused of abuse found them innocent, the Legion said.

The scandal of Maciel and the Legion ranks as one of the worst of the 20th-century Catholic Church, since he was held up as a model for the faithful by Pope John Paul II. The orthodox order, which has about 900 priests around the world, was praised for attracting both money and vocations to the priesthood.

Documentation from Vatican archives, however, has shown that as early as the 1950s, the Vatican had evidence that he was a drug addict and pedophile.

Only in 2006 did the Vatican sanction Maciel to a lifetime of penance and prayer for his crimes. He died in 2008 and a year later the Legion admitted he had fathered three children with two different women and had abused his seminarians.

The Vatican took over the Legion in 2010 and is pushing through a process of reform.

Aaron Loughrey, 35, was a 17- or 18-year-old Legion seminarian in Ireland in the spring of 1995 when he says he was forced by a superior to masturbate him in bed. Loughrey, who left the Legion before being ordained, says he has been in counseling almost ever since as he seeks justice from the order.

He said that the vow he took as a seminarian never to criticize the actions or deeds of a superior made him unable to question what the priest had told him to do. In a parallel to the way Maciel abused his seminarians, Loughrey says his superior had told him that an unnamed illness gave him terrible cramps in his lower abdomen that could only be eased with massage.

“In my heart and in my conscience I believed that I had acted that night like a true Legionary — putting my superior’s needs before my own — and I stuffed the unsavory thoughts and feelings to the back of my mind,” Loughrey has written.

The priest has since left the priesthood. Pope Benedict XVI in 2007 ordered the Legion to remove the so-called fourth vow never to criticize a superior — precisely because of the abuse of authority that it had created in the order.

____________________________

Vatican ‘probes Legion of Christ priests over child abuse’

BBC News Europe

11 May 2012

The Vatican is reported to be investigating seven priests of the Legion of Christ order in connection with allegations of child abuse.

In a statement to the AP news agency, the Mexican order said seven cases had been referred to the Vatican’s department that deals with sex crimes.

The Legion of Christ’s founder, Marcial Maciel, sexually abused many boys and young men over a period of 30 years.

He was disciplined by the Vatican in 2006 over the abuse.

One of the cases being investigated in relation to the seven priests is recent, while others date back several decades, the order said in the statement given to AP.

The investigation will be handled by the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican office that investigates allegations of sexual abuse.

While it is under way, the suspects will be kept away from children.

‘Immoral acts’

“Over the past few years, in several countries, the major superiors of the Legion of Christ have received some allegations of gravely immoral acts and more serious offences… committed by some legionaries,” AP quoted the statement as saying.

The order has previously insisted that Fr Maciel was an isolated case.

The BBC’s Alan Johnston in Rome says that if these new allegations are proven it will show that the rot in the order had spread beyond its disgraced leader.

In 2009, the Church launched an investigation into the order after Fr Maciel, who died in 2008, was also revealed to have fathered a daughter by a mistress.

A year later, Pope Benedict XVI appointed an envoy to implement a complete overhaul of the Legion of Christ, saying it had to be “purified”.

The previous pope, John Paul II, long held up Fr Maciel as a model to the faithful, despite persistent allegations of sexual abuse, which were later proven.

In recent years, the Church has been rocked by cases of paedophilia by priests, and accusations that it did not do enough to investigate the allegations.

3 Responses to Vatican Eyes Legion Priests on Abuse

  1. Sylvia says:

    The Legionaries should have been disbanded.  I can not conceive why an order founded by a clerical sexual predator is allowed to carry on. 

    Note the following sentence: “While the investigation is under way, the accused priests are being kept away from children, the Legion said.”  I take it this means these priests  have NOT been suspended pending the outcome of the investigation?

    How pray tell are these men being kept away from children?  And who is doing the ‘keeping away’? And, who are the priests under investigation?

  2. Mike Mc says:

    He said that the vow he took as a seminarian never to criticize the actions or deeds of a superior made him unable to question what the priest had told him to do. In a parallel to the way Maciel abused his seminarians, Loughrey says his superior had told him that an unnamed illness gave him terrible cramps in his lower abdomen that could only be eased with massage.

    It’s obvious the whole sexual nature of this lifestyle is a battlefield. I used to think of the priesthood as a “call”. It’s my old Catholic upbringing. Now I see the priesthood and its attempt at celibacy as unnatural. It is just not normal. These men are frustrated and ill at ease with their natural sexual thoughts and desires.

    This branch of the Church should be disbanded, especially since its founder set the wrong example.

    It’s time the Church address marriage in the priesthood. I do admit that marriage is not necessairly a solution to all these abusive problems. But it’s a start. The Church has to review all its thinking here. Probably take another 2000 years, however.

    Sad!

  3. Sylvia says:

    The priesthood is a calling Mike Mc.  That doesn’t mean there aren’t imposters.  

    As you know we don’t agree on the marriage business, but, in truth that is a discipline of the Church and, being a discipline,  could change.  I doubt that it will, but it could be changed.  There are, for example, already some ex-Anglican married priests who  have been received into the Church  and now, married as they are, serve as Catholic priests.

    But do you really and truly think that marriage would have solved Father Maciel’s problems?  Goodness, Maciel had women on the side, and he molested his own son, and he molested I don’t know how many young lads. I don’t think there was anything “natural” about his thoughts and inclinations at all. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *