Home
Cover-up
Garry Guzzo
Institutions
Leduc Trial
Media
Of Interest
Perry Dunlop
Questions
Red Flags
The AG
The Clan
The Diocese
The Inquiry
The Scandal
The Trials
The Victims
cornwall

the inquiry


Cornwall Public Inquiry

The Victims
INQUIRY: Lawyer says Victims need answers 'before they can move forward'

   

Cornwall Standard Freeholder  

24 February 2009  

Posted By DAVID NESSETH

Victims Group lawyer Dallas Lee said he wanted to balance his oral phase one submissions between looking back and looking forward.

 

He said his clients eagerly await the findings of Commissioner Normand Glaude realtive to the institutional response surrounding sexual abuse complaints.

 

"They need answers before they can move forward," Lee said.

 

He recalled the expert testimony of David Wolfe -- the Cornwall Public Inquiry's first witness -- in order to detail for the public some of the effects of childhood sexual abuse.

 

"It can so thoroughly devastate the victims that investigations and prosecutions become more difficult," Lee said.

 

Sexual abuse isn't like a broken bone, Lee added, noting that the wounds can often last a lifetime. For some clients, he said, there was the additional punishment of some of the abused children losing their faith and trust in the church.

 

Lee adressed the "secrecy" that surrounded priests within the Roman Catholic Diocese of Alexandria-Cornwall. He described the Catholic church as having an "internal legal framework that is built around secrecy and a pre-disposition to work against the victim and in favour of accused priests."

  

 The Victims Group recommended government intervention into diocese responses to sexual abuse by clergy and a formal sexual abuse protocol that would become part of the local diocesan law. It also recommended that offending priests should not be returned to parishes or other ministry.

CRITICIZED PROBATION OFFICE, SCHOOL BOARD

 

Lee also criticized the response of the local probation office and a local school board in respect to sexual abuse allegations. He said it's "cold comfort" to his clients that society has become more vigilant at protecting children. Children, he added, "whose childhood horrors were only exacerbated by the Children's Aid Society's (CAS) intervention."

 

Similar to the Coalition for Action, Lee recommended that CAS treat client files as belonging to its clients, not CAS. He said the files should be provided automatically to the clients after they leave its care.

  

Lee also explored some of the complexities of the Cornwall Community Police Service's handling of the David Silmser case, notably by former chief Claude Shaver.

 

"Shaver's own shameful performance as a witness at the Inquiry closed a sad chapter in this community's history," Lee said.

 

He suggested that after reading the recent phase one submission by the Cornwall police, it's clear the force has learned next to nothing since the time of events that led to the inquiry.

 

He challenged Commissioner Glaude to find admissions or concessions on any key points in the submission by local police.

 

Lee read directly into the record the Victims Group statement on Const. Perry Dunlop: "The reasons that Dunlop and the community lost faith in their institutions and the effects of that lost faith are the real issues," Lee said.

 

He also examined some of the barriers that made it difficult for his clients to report sexual abuse, as well as the confusion it created in the context of their sexual identities.

 

Article ID# 1448240

  


 Comments on this Article. 

"Due process my *ss", the only due process was the cover-up that started and still goes on this very day>


As for this so-called Inquiry having the power to impact sexual abuse on a national scale, please read the Provincial Advocates Annual Report and you'll begin to understand why NOTHING will get done of any consequence whether provincial or nationally. As for your comment oh "silentnomore" regarding Perry Dunlop, he got the "shaft" from the system including his own force many times over, so if you think that what the coppers and the system did to Perry is OK, I guess you're in a dream world as they gave the victims the shaft by not doing something about it way back then. The cops, CAS, CCAS's, Min of C&Y oh and we can't forget the church in all this, all the way up to "Tricky Dick" our esteemed dictator for a few years will continue to cover their collective *sses as they have been doing all over this province for decades and decades and the abuse did and still does continue on unabated and will continue until laws are put in to hang the bastards who abuse ANY child and I'd gladly pull the lever to open the trap door. And oh yeh "silentnomore", your style of writing does quite well in giving us a hint as to the crap of silentnomore, you never were, just a different alias!!
Re: Child Advocate's Annual Report

To Y'all:
 I just finished reading Irwin's report and was talking with the
Star's Laurie who wrote the front page piece in today's Star. I also
talked with a reporter from the Sun and told him to check out Vivien
Song's column and Sam Pazzanno's column that they did when I brought
my case and problems within the "System" to their attention when we
were covering the "Jeffrey Baldwin" case at the Superior Court. I
told them that the Min of C&Y had a 40 page fax since 2004/5 that
they refused to answer to regarding a lot of these same conditions. I
was talking with Irwin's office today and they're calling me back as
I have offered them all of my files from the HWCAS, the 2CD's
recorded by the IPC during a tele-conference Adjudication against the
police and all of the paper-work that has been generated between me,
the HWCAS, the Hamilton cops in my 2nd FOI Request that has been
ongoing for 4 years and the reporter is calling me back. Also, I was
talking with Andrea Horwath's Executive Assistant Sheila White about
all of this as they have been "guiding" me for many years, good
people they both are, so I guess we'll see what happens from here on.
By the way, in that 40 page fax mentioned above, I bring up the fact
that neither the various CAS's & CCAS's nor the Min of C&Y will
provide NO statistics regarding kids under the age of 18 in their care
(?) and when the kids turn 18, the door is open and the CAS &
CCAS "wipe their hands" of these people (US!!!)! Nobody knows and or
cares about what happens to these kids and also, how do they know if
the "System" is working right if they don't evaluate their own stats
and the stats once the kids are released. We know and so do they but
with their "super immunity" they don't have to tell and also my
complaint about the Advocate having only the powers to "review" and
make "recommendations" with NO OVER-SITE powers to actually do
anything and that the whole thing should be given over to the
Ombudsman but it would appear that Irwin has a fine stubborn streak
in him and it doesn't seem like he's going to let them get away with
it. Any-who, I keep y'all up to date when I hear more. Dave
 

Reply | Report | Page Top Post #1 By grimreaper_47,

Dave with your attitude and outlook it makes it difficult to want to help or even care 

Reply | Report | Page Top Post #2 By itinerant,